Unresolved Tensions in Sociocultural Theory: Analogies with Contemporary Sociological Debates
نویسنده
چکیده
Socioculturalists are divided on two of the foundational theoretical claims of the paradigm: a process ontology of the social world; and the inseparability of the individual and the group. A process ontology holds that only processes are real; entities, structures or patterns are ephemeral and do not really exist. Inseparability is the claim that the individual and the social cannot be methodologically or ontologically distinguished. To clarify the different stances toward these claims held by socioculturalists, I draw on the contemporary sociological debate between Anthony Giddens and Margaret Archer. Giddens’ structuration theory holds to a process ontology and to inseparability, while Archer’s emergentist theory rejects both. I borrow the terms of this debate to clarify the tensions among several prominent socioculturalists, including Cole, Lave and Wenger, Rogoff, Shweder, Valsiner, and Wertsch. I argue that a strong form of inseparability is theoretically problematic and empirically untenable, and I conclude that socioculturalists can resolve these tensions by adopting an ‘analytic dualism’ that retains key sociocultural commitments.
منابع مشابه
Sociocultural theory 1 Unresolved tensions in sociocultural theory: Analogies with contemporary sociological debates Running head: UNRESOLVED TENSIONS IN SOCIOCULTURAL THEORY
Socioculturalists are divided on two of the foundational theoretical claims of the paradigm: a process ontology of the social world, and the inseparability of the individual and the group. A process ontology holds that only processes are real; entities, structures, or patterns are ephemeral and do not really exist. Inseparability is the claim that the individual and the social cannot be methodo...
متن کاملCurrent Issues and Debates in SLA
The existing scholarship on Second Language Acquisition is replete with different tensions and debates, which reflect diverging epistemologies, theoretical bases and schools of thought. This paper deals with the current issues surrounding the two major and salient approaches to Second Language Acquisition, the cognitive/psycholinguistic camp and the sociocultural camp. After providing an overvi...
متن کاملEmergence in Sociology
Many accounts of the micro-macro link use the philosophical notion of emergence to argue that collective phenomena are collaboratively created by individuals yet are not reducible to explanation in terms of individuals. However, emergence has also been invoked by methodological individualists; they accept the existence of emergent social properties yet claim that such properties can be reduced ...
متن کاملAnalytical Study of the Social Values and Norms of Youth in Saddi's Gulistan Based on Contemporary Sociological Theories
Iran is the cradle of literature, culture and ethics. Paying attention to ethics has always been considered by sages as an important necessity. There were also some poets who had the sociological look upon the society, in addition to relying on moral and social issues. Saadi is one of those poets whose works has overtaken others. He illuminates and deals with the roots of social problems like a...
متن کاملJALDA's Interview with Professor James P. Lantolf
James P. Lantolf is George and Jane Greer Professor Emeritus of Language Acquisition and Applied Linguistics and former director of the Center for Advanced Language Proficiency Education and Research at the Pennsylvania State University, USA. He is currently Adjunct Professor of Applied Linguistics in the same academic unit at Xi’an Jiaotong University. He is founder of the Sociocultural Theory...
متن کامل